Retail
Subscription
to Advertise
  • ISSUES
    • 1996 to 1999
      • 1996
        • May 1996
        • June 1996
        • July 1996
        • August 1996
        • September 1996
        • October 1996
        • November 1996
        • December 1996
      • 1997
    • 2000 to 2009
      • 2006
        • January 2006
        • February 2006
        • March 2006
        • April 2006
        • May 2006
        • June 2006
        • July 2006
        • August 2006
        • September 2006
        • October 2006
        • November 2006
        • December 2006
      • 2007
        • March 2007
        • April 2007
        • May 2007
        • July 2007
        • August 2007
        • September 2007
        • November 2007
        • December 2007
      • 2008
        • January 2008
        • February 2008
        • March 2008
        • April 2008
        • May 2008
        • June 2008
        • July 2008
        • August 2008
        • September 2008
        • October 2008
        • November 2008
        • December 2008
      • 2009
        • January 2009
        • February 2009
        • March 2009
        • April 2009
        • May 2009
        • June 2009
        • June 2009
        • July 2009
        • August 2009
        • September 2009
        • October 2009
        • November 2009
        • December 2009
    • 2010 to 2019
      • 2010
        • January 2010
        • February 2010
        • March 2010
        • April 2010
        • May 2010
        • June 2010
        • July 2010
        • August 2010
        • December 2010
      • 2011
        • January 2011
        • February 2011
        • March 2011
        • April 2011
        • May 2011
        • June 2011
        • July 2011
        • August 2011
        • September 2011
        • October 2011
        • November 2011
        • December 2011
      • 2012
        • January 2012
        • February 2012
        • March 2012
        • April 2012
        • May 2012
        • June 2012
        • July 2012
        • August 2012
        • September 2012
        • October 2012
        • November 2012
        • December 2012
      • 2013
        • January 2013
        • February 2013
        • March 2013
        • April 2013
        • May 2013
        • June 2013
        • July 2013
        • August 2013
        • September 2013
        • November 2013
        • December 2013
      • 2014
        • January 2014
        • February 2014
        • March 2014
        • April 2014
        • May 2014
        • June 2014
        • July 2014
        • August 2014
        • September 2014
        • October 2014
        • November 2014
        • December 2014
      • 2015
        • January 2015
        • February 2015
        • March 2015
        • April 2015
        • May 2015
        • June 2015
        • July 2015
        • August 2015
        • September 2015
        • October 2015
        • November 2015
        • December 2015
      • 2016
        • January 2016
        • February 2016
        • March 2016
        • April 2016
        • May 2016
        • June 2016
        • July 2016
        • August 2016
        • October 2016
        • November 2016
        • December 2016
      • 2017
        • January 2017
        • February 2017
        • March 2017
        • April 2017
        • May 2017
        • June 2017
        • July 2017
        • August 2017
        • September 2017
        • October 2017
        • November 2017
        • December 2017
      • 2018
        • January 2018
        • February 2018
        • March 2018
        • April 2018
        • May 2018
        • June 2018
        • July 2018
        • August 2018
        • September 2018
        • October 2018
        • November 2018
        • December 2018
      • 2019
        • January 2019
        • February 2019
        • March 2019
        • April 2019
        • May 2019
        • June 2019
        • July 2019
        • August 2019
        • September 2019
        • October 2019
        • November 2019
        • December 2019
    • 2020 to 2023
      • 2020
        • January 2020
        • February 2020
        • March 2020
        • April 2020
        • May 2020
        • June 2020
        • July 2020
        • August 2020
        • September 2020
        • October 2020
        • November 2020
        • December 2020
      • 2021
        • January 2021
        • February 2021
        • March 2021
        • April 2021
        • May 2021
        • June 2021
        • July 2021
        • August 2021
        • September 2021
        • October 2021
        • November 2021
        • December 2021
      • 2022
        • January 2022
        • June 2022
        • February 2022
        • July 2022
        • March 2022
        • April 2022
        • August 2022
        • May 2022
        • December 2022
      • 2023
        • January 2023
        • February 2023
        • March 2023
        • July 2023
        • April 2023
        • May 2023
        • June 2023
  • FOR DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTION
  • BT AWARDS
    • BT Top 40
      • BT Top 40 2021 – 2022
    • BT Top 30
      • BT Top 30 2018 – 2019
    • BT Top 25
      • BT Top 25 2011 – 2012
      • BT Top 25 2012 – 2013
      • BT Top 25 2013 – 2014
    • BT Top 20
      • BT Top 20 2009 – 2010
      • BT Top 20 2010 – 2011
    • BT Top 10
      • BT Top 10 2008 – 2009
      • BT Top 10 2007 – 2008
      • BT Top 10 2006 – 2007
      • BT Top 10 2005 – 2006
      • BT Top 10 2003 – 2004
      • BT Top 10 2000 – 2001
      • BT Top 10 1999 – 2000
      • BT Top 10 1998 – 1999
      • BT Top 10 1997 – 1998
      • BT Top 10 1996 – 1997
      • BT Top 10 1995 – 1996
  • ABOUT US
No Result
View All Result
Business Today
No Result
View All Result

Identifying Impediments: Privatisation needs Lubricating

in September 2006
0

Trevor Reckerman, Jt. Managing Director of Mclarens Lubricants, in an interview with Sassanka Samarakkody highlights the shortcomings in the privatisation process with regard to the lubricant industry and the resultant negative impact on the company’s business.

When the petroleum industry, which was a state monop­oly, was partially opened up in the mid-1990s for private sector investment, five multi-national play­ers entered the market. Among them was McLarens Lubricants, distributor in Sri Lanka of the international brand Exxon Mobil. At the initial stages of the privati­sation process, the manufacture and distribution of gas went to Shell, and Caltex obtained lubricants. Both these entities monopolised the market for about five years. “At that stage, from a state mo­nopoly it became a private sector monopoly, with Caltex entering the market as the sole manufacturer,” Reckerman explained. “In 1999, five other players were permitted to enter the lubricant business, which included McLarens Lubricants, but only to mar­ket products – not to manufacture. 

“All five private sector entities were multi-national companies and each of us paid the sum of Rs 5m to get the licence, which was valid up to end 2005.” However, according to Recker­man, although at this juncture the mo­nopoly of Caltex seemingly ended, in effect it continued. “Because the duty difference between our products and Caltex at market level was 25%. This as a huge gap and meant that Caltex was able to market their products at much cheaper rate t n the other five players in the field. “The reason given by P C (Public Enterprises Reform Commission) was that they needed to protect the local entity, Caltex, which had bought into a major portion of the Ceylon Petroleum Corporation (CPC). “At the time we entered into the agreement with PERC, it said the duty difference would be 10%. But one month later the gap increased to 15% and finally to 25%. We have protested to the authorities about this unfair treatment, but not much was done.” 

Another factor that has hindered the growth of the industry was a countervailing clause in the 1995 agreement with the private sector companies, which said that none of the other companies could sell at less than Caltex. This was a further blow to our business and our intention of conduct-ing a viable business began to slowly evaporate,” Reckerman observed. Explaining further, he said: “The traditional lubricant marketing channel was the network of Petroleum Corporation sheds or stations. However, these were reserved for Caltex products and none of the other companies could enter that channel. We therefore sold lubricants where we could, such as in tyre shops and other outlets. To give an example of how unfairly we were treated, we won a tender to supply lubricants to the Ceylon Electricity Board (CEB). However, soon after we won it, the tender was cancelled. We were later made to understand that the tender was awarded to Caltex, considering the fact that CEB was a government entity. We went to court against this decision and it ended up with us hav­ing to contest the cabinet appointed tender board, but our principals were not keen to pursue the matter because they believed it would be an unfriendly act. “The point I wish to make is that if a certain sector is privatised, then the investor interest should also be safeguarded. This certainly is not happening at least as far as the lu­bricant sector is concerned. We find that in many instances, PERC just goes through the motions of privatis­ing a sector and then simply washes its hand of it; there is no monitoring or follow-up action to support the industry.

Reckerman says foreign enti­ties that look to do business in Sri­Lanka want some safeguards and there should be some intervention by PERC. “For instance, they should be flexible enough to revise a clause in an agreement if it has a negative impact on the industry and hinder its growth. Nothing like this is happening. In 2005, the agreements of all the private companies, including the agreement with Caltex, came to an end. “But it appeared that the govern­ment was not ready to move forward and we were told to continue with the agreements as they were. Therefore the status quo remained and with a change of government, nothing really happened. “Then in January 2006 we were suddenly summoned by PERC and told that in order to renew our licence, we have to pay a further sum of RslO million, calculated at Rs2m per year.

At the time we signed the agreement in 1995, we were made to understand that the licence fee of Rs5m was a one­time payment. “They also wanted others to enter the market. I guess someone had made a calculation based on the licence fee and decided this was a good way to get some additional revenue to the state coffers. Caltex too had to pay a licence fee this time round. Earlier, since they bought into the CPC, the question of a licence fee had not arisen. “We have suggested to PERC that in that case, we should be permitted to enter the manufacturing field, which is presently monopolised by Caltex. in order for us to become a profitable entity. This will now come to pass with the recent RFQ (Request For Qualification) announced by PERC. However it will be interesting to study if the economies of scale support such a venture. In such a scenario, we need to have a large offshore market, which presently is commanded by countries like Singapore and Dubai, who are conducting very efficient operations. “We also told PERC that since they wanted us to pay a further li­cence fee, the market should not be opened to more players, because the lubricant market is very small – its around six to seven percent growth per year.

“Anyhow, PERC has called for expression of interest for more com­panies to enter the market and the applications closed on August 28. We believe that, if at all, there should be no more than 10 players, and they should all be reputable companies. Otherwise the market will only frag­ment and investments will simply dry up. “At the same time, why should we pay a huge licence fee when we are not getting any privileges for it? Other industries do not pay any licence fee. Even the original licence was of no benefit to us – we only managed to survive, but got nothing in return.”

The government is looking at in­ternationally recognised companies, rated according to API (American Pe­troleum Institute) standards. “That is a reasonable approach. Local compa­nies must be encouraged to participate so long as the accepted international standards are maintained. However, this may be difficult as the market was closed for 10 years, but with the right collaboration these barriers can be overcome,” he said. Reckerman is of the view that pri­vate companies were able to survive so far because they are all multi-na­tional entities, marketing a quality product. “For all of us it has been a strug­gle. We have not lost but our profit margins are minimal.

“Local companies must be encouraged to participate so long as the accepted international standards are maintained. However, this may be difficult as the market was closed for 10 years, but with the right collaboration these barriers can be overcome.”

As for Mobil, we are an international brand repre­sented in all sectors. Next to Caltex, we are number two in the market and cover automobile, industrial, marine, aviation and the power sectors. In fact we cover the entire gamut, and not many companies can boast of this feat. “We also have a very strong presence in the synthetic market – we have a certain leadership there. I could say we are also the preferred oil supplier to all the franchise car companies. Most of the top compa­nies have tied up with us for the supply of their lubricants. Unlike the older vehicles that go for cheaper oils new vehicles look for quality. We are therefore strongly represented in the new vehicle market and have tied up with Mercedes, BMW, Toyota, Audi, Subaru, etc. As far as I can see, Honda is the only renowned brand that’s not with us.

“That itself shows our strength in the market, but what we don’t have are the critical numbers. Even if all the five companies are put together, the turnover does not add up to a billion rupees.” Reckerman says that considering the current situation, with labour un­rest in the petroleum sector as well as the work in the Colombo Port being disrupted due to regular strike action by employees, many major foreign investors might not be keen to invest in Sri Lanka. “They have alternative invest­ment destinations like Singapore and Dubai,” he pointed out. “We have to give good reasons as to why such companies should consider do­ing business in this country. Maybe small operators may be interested, but as for international entities, I have my doubts.”

He is of the view that as far as the State is concerned, there is a lack of understanding and knowledge about how the private sector operates and especially the dynamics of the mod­ern lubricant industry. “After the liberalisation of the economy all governments have been talking about a level playing field, where the private sector could com­pete with the public sector. But the reality is quite different.” According to Reckerman, there were a number of impediments to an open and transparent process of privatisation. What is taking place right now is “survival of the fittest,” he claimed. 

 

Business Today August 2023

Business Today September 2023

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

© 2023 BT Options. All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • ISSUES
    • 1996 to 1999
      • 1996
      • 1997
    • 2000 to 2009
      • 2006
      • 2007
      • 2008
      • 2009
    • 2010 to 2019
      • 2010
      • 2011
      • 2012
      • 2013
      • 2014
      • 2015
      • 2016
      • 2017
      • 2018
      • 2019
    • 2020 to 2023
      • 2020
      • 2021
      • 2022
      • 2023
  • FOR DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTION
  • BT AWARDS
    • BT Top 40
      • BT Top 40 2021 – 2022
    • BT Top 30
      • BT Top 30 2018 – 2019
    • BT Top 25
      • BT Top 25 2011 – 2012
      • BT Top 25 2012 – 2013
      • BT Top 25 2013 – 2014
    • BT Top 20
      • BT Top 20 2009 – 2010
      • BT Top 20 2010 – 2011
    • BT Top 10
      • BT Top 10 2008 – 2009
      • BT Top 10 2007 – 2008
      • BT Top 10 2006 – 2007
      • BT Top 10 2005 – 2006
      • BT Top 10 2003 – 2004
      • BT Top 10 2000 – 2001
      • BT Top 10 1999 – 2000
      • BT Top 10 1998 – 1999
      • BT Top 10 1997 – 1998
      • BT Top 10 1996 – 1997
      • BT Top 10 1995 – 1996
  • ABOUT US

© 2023 BT Options. All Rights Reserved