Retail
Subscription
to Advertise
  • ISSUES
    • 1996 to 1999
      • 1996
        • May 1996
        • June 1996
        • July 1996
        • August 1996
        • September 1996
        • October 1996
        • November 1996
        • December 1996
      • 1997
    • 2000 to 2009
      • 2006
        • January 2006
        • February 2006
        • March 2006
        • April 2006
        • May 2006
        • June 2006
        • July 2006
        • August 2006
        • September 2006
        • October 2006
        • November 2006
        • December 2006
      • 2007
        • March 2007
        • April 2007
        • May 2007
        • July 2007
        • August 2007
        • September 2007
        • November 2007
        • December 2007
      • 2008
        • January 2008
        • February 2008
        • March 2008
        • April 2008
        • May 2008
        • June 2008
        • July 2008
        • August 2008
        • September 2008
        • October 2008
        • November 2008
        • December 2008
      • 2009
        • January 2009
        • February 2009
        • March 2009
        • April 2009
        • May 2009
        • June 2009
        • June 2009
        • July 2009
        • August 2009
        • September 2009
        • October 2009
        • November 2009
        • December 2009
    • 2010 to 2019
      • 2010
        • January 2010
        • February 2010
        • March 2010
        • April 2010
        • May 2010
        • June 2010
        • July 2010
        • August 2010
        • December 2010
      • 2011
        • January 2011
        • February 2011
        • March 2011
        • April 2011
        • May 2011
        • June 2011
        • July 2011
        • August 2011
        • September 2011
        • October 2011
        • November 2011
        • December 2011
      • 2012
        • January 2012
        • February 2012
        • March 2012
        • April 2012
        • May 2012
        • June 2012
        • July 2012
        • August 2012
        • September 2012
        • October 2012
        • November 2012
        • December 2012
      • 2013
        • January 2013
        • February 2013
        • March 2013
        • April 2013
        • May 2013
        • June 2013
        • July 2013
        • August 2013
        • September 2013
        • November 2013
        • December 2013
      • 2014
        • January 2014
        • February 2014
        • March 2014
        • April 2014
        • May 2014
        • June 2014
        • July 2014
        • August 2014
        • September 2014
        • October 2014
        • November 2014
        • December 2014
      • 2015
        • January 2015
        • February 2015
        • March 2015
        • April 2015
        • May 2015
        • June 2015
        • July 2015
        • August 2015
        • September 2015
        • October 2015
        • November 2015
        • December 2015
      • 2016
        • January 2016
        • February 2016
        • March 2016
        • April 2016
        • May 2016
        • June 2016
        • July 2016
        • August 2016
        • October 2016
        • November 2016
        • December 2016
      • 2017
        • January 2017
        • February 2017
        • March 2017
        • April 2017
        • May 2017
        • June 2017
        • July 2017
        • August 2017
        • September 2017
        • October 2017
        • November 2017
        • December 2017
      • 2018
        • January 2018
        • February 2018
        • March 2018
        • April 2018
        • May 2018
        • June 2018
        • July 2018
        • August 2018
        • September 2018
        • October 2018
        • November 2018
        • December 2018
      • 2019
        • January 2019
        • February 2019
        • March 2019
        • April 2019
        • May 2019
        • June 2019
        • July 2019
        • August 2019
        • September 2019
        • October 2019
        • November 2019
        • December 2019
    • 2020 to 2023
      • 2020
        • January 2020
        • February 2020
        • March 2020
        • April 2020
        • May 2020
        • June 2020
        • July 2020
        • August 2020
        • September 2020
        • October 2020
        • November 2020
        • December 2020
      • 2021
        • January 2021
        • February 2021
        • March 2021
        • April 2021
        • May 2021
        • June 2021
        • July 2021
        • August 2021
        • September 2021
        • October 2021
        • November 2021
        • December 2021
      • 2022
        • January 2022
        • June 2022
        • February 2022
        • July 2022
        • March 2022
        • April 2022
        • August 2022
        • May 2022
        • December 2022
      • 2023
        • January 2023
        • February 2023
        • March 2023
        • July 2023
        • April 2023
        • May 2023
        • June 2023
        • July 2023
        • August 2023
        • September 2023
        • October 2023
        • November 2023
  • FOR DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTION
  • BT AWARDS
    • BT Top 40
      • BT Top 40 2021 – 2022
    • BT Top 30
      • BT Top 30 2015 – 2016
      • BT Top 30 2016 – 2017
      • BT Top 30 2017 – 2018
      • BT Top 30 2018 – 2019
    • BT Top 25
      • BT Top 25 2011 – 2012
      • BT Top 25 2012 – 2013
      • BT Top 25 2013 – 2014
      • BT Top 25 2014 – 2015
    • BT Top 20
      • BT Top 20 2009 – 2010
      • BT Top 20 2010 – 2011
    • BT Top 10
      • BT Top 10 2008 – 2009
      • BT Top 10 2007 – 2008
      • BT Top 10 2006 – 2007
      • BT Top 10 2005 – 2006
      • BT Top 10 2003 – 2004
      • BT Top 10 2000 – 2001
      • BT Top 10 1999 – 2000
      • BT Top 10 1998 – 1999
      • BT Top 10 1997 – 1998
      • BT Top 10 1996 – 1997
      • BT Top 10 1995 – 1996
  • ABOUT US
No Result
View All Result
Business Today
No Result
View All Result

Accused: HSBC In The Dock

in August 2012, Featured
0
image_pdfDownload as PDF

Helping sanctions-busting by Iran. Turning a blind eye to massive cash transfers out of a Mexican border area infested with drugs gangs. Refusing to cut off a Saudi bank suspected of having links to al-Qa’ida. Funnelling hundreds of millions of dollars in suspicious travellers cheques from Russian “used-car salesmen” through Japan to the US. Ignoring its own employees who warned that the bank was awash with dirty money.


Stephen Foley / The Independent / The Interview People


A US Senate committee has just published a list of HSBC’s failures to catch suspicious transactions and clamp down on money laundering, and it is a very long list indeed. A laundry list, if you like.


It took Senator Carl Levin, the man in charge of the Homeland Security sub-committee, half an hour to recite even the main charges when HSBC executives were hauled in for a Congressional hearing. It took the executives even longer to recite their list of apologies and promises that HSBC is cleaning up its act.


And for the largest London-listed bank, the humiliation of the Senate hearing might not even be the half of it. The Department of Justice believes it has more than enough evidence of compliance failures across the bank to slap enormous fines on the company. Analysts are bracing themselves to hear about a legal settlement that could cost HSBC up to $1bn, perhaps within the next few weeks. For Stuart Gulliver, the settlement and hearing amount to public atonement for a decade of wrongs, but when it comes to fixing the failures, executives warned that would take more time – and money – yet.


In 340 damning pages, Mr Levin’s permanent sub-committee on investigations sets out how HSBC repeatedly put the pursuit of profit ahead of rooting out money laundering. The report stretches back to 2001 and covers a full decade, alleging that repeated attempts by employees to point out compliance failings were ignored by higher-up managers.


When HSBC managers advised Iran’s largest bank on ways to avoid having its transactions held up by US filters, introduced as part of sanctions on the regime, one executive wrote an email saying: “I wish to be on the record as not comfortable with this piece of business.” Executives, including the former HSBC chief executive Stephen Green, now Britain’s Trade Minister, discussed how to continue doing business with Iran and stay in compliance with US law; the sub-committee alleges that by stripping transactions of details about their country of origin, HSBC facilitated 25,000 questionable payments involving Iran in the six years to 2007.


In another case, HSBC resumed business with a Saudi Arabian lender, Rajhi Bank, over the objections of some executives, despite US insistence that Rajhi’s founder had been a backer of al-Qa’ida. And the sub-committee found that HSBC cleared $290m in “obviously suspicious” US travellers cheques for a Japanese bank, benefiting Russians who claimed to be in the used-car business.


Some of the worst failures were at HSBC’s Mexican bank, Bital, which it acquired in 2002. Even while other global banks were pulling back on their dealings with casas de cambio – local money-changing operations used to send cash abroad, HSBC carried on with Bital’s fast-paced growth and failed to implement many of the anti-money laundering checks required of banks with US operations.


Paul Thurston, who now runs HSBC’s retail banking and wealth-management operations, but who was “for 14 stressful months” in 2007 and 2008 the head of the Mexico bank, told Congress: “Some of the things I found, frankly, took my breath away.”


The sub-committee report found that HSBC Mexico’s top anti-money laundering official warned head office before leaving the company in 2008 that there was “a culture of pursuing profits and targets at all costs [and it was] only a matter of time before the bank faced criminal sanctions”.

HSBC Should Have Been Threatened With The Removal Of Its Banking Licence In The US, But Regulators Gave The Bank Only Minor Sanctions And Warnings Until The Criminal Investigation Began In Earnest Towards The End Of The Last Decade.


“Accountability for past conduct is essential,” Senator Levin told the hearing yesterday. “That’s what’s been missing here.”


He said HSBC should have been threatened with the removal of its banking licence in the US, but regulators gave the bank only minor sanctions and warnings until the criminal investigation began in earnest towards the end of the last decade.


In all, six current and former HSBC executives testified before Congress yesterday, in what was billed as a “case study” into how the US banking system can be contaminated by drugs money and terrorist financing, and into how HSBC helped Mexico’s vicious drug gangs grow in strength by laundering the proceeds of their trade on America’s streets. Irene Dorner, who was appointed last year to head HSBC’s North American operations, admitted that the bank’s compliance practices had been simply “unacceptable”. She said: “I fully appreciate why we are here.”


HSBC’s net income last year was $16.8bn. It operates in about 80 countries and its US division is among the top 10 banks operating in the US, with assets of $210bn. Executives admitted HSBC had underfunded its anti-money laundering effort for years, and said it had raised the budget ninefold since 2010. But while they set out their own list of ways in which it had cleaned up its act since regulators and prosecutors moved in, including imposing new standards directly from London, they also warned that all the steps required by watchdogs had not yet been met.


David Bagley, who had been HSBC’s head of group compliance since 2002, stepped down immediately after the committee published its findings.


Mr Bagley, who had a 20-year career with HSBC and was based in London, said: “Despite the best efforts and intentions of many dedicated professionals, HSBC has fallen short of our own expectations and the expectations of our regulators.”


Ms Dorner said: “We need to respond not only to regulatory changes but also to advances in technology to the risks posed by the ingenuity of drug traffickers, money launderers, tax evaders and others seeking to use our financial system for illicit purposes. We want our doors to be closed to these bad actors. This is my goal.”

Business Today December 2023

business-today-logo

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

© 2023 BT Options. All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • ISSUES
    • 1996 to 1999
      • 1996
      • 1997
    • 2000 to 2009
      • 2006
      • 2007
      • 2008
      • 2009
    • 2010 to 2019
      • 2010
      • 2011
      • 2012
      • 2013
      • 2014
      • 2015
      • 2016
      • 2017
      • 2018
      • 2019
    • 2020 to 2023
      • 2020
      • 2021
      • 2022
      • 2023
  • FOR DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTION
  • BT AWARDS
    • BT Top 40
      • BT Top 40 2021 – 2022
    • BT Top 30
      • BT Top 30 2015 – 2016
      • BT Top 30 2016 – 2017
      • BT Top 30 2017 – 2018
      • BT Top 30 2018 – 2019
    • BT Top 25
      • BT Top 25 2011 – 2012
      • BT Top 25 2012 – 2013
      • BT Top 25 2013 – 2014
      • BT Top 25 2014 – 2015
    • BT Top 20
      • BT Top 20 2009 – 2010
      • BT Top 20 2010 – 2011
    • BT Top 10
      • BT Top 10 2008 – 2009
      • BT Top 10 2007 – 2008
      • BT Top 10 2006 – 2007
      • BT Top 10 2005 – 2006
      • BT Top 10 2003 – 2004
      • BT Top 10 2000 – 2001
      • BT Top 10 1999 – 2000
      • BT Top 10 1998 – 1999
      • BT Top 10 1997 – 1998
      • BT Top 10 1996 – 1997
      • BT Top 10 1995 – 1996
  • ABOUT US

© 2023 BT Options. All Rights Reserved